Tuesday, September 1, 2015

CYCLE OF VIOLENCE (Part 3) ON HUMAN RIGHTS, GENDER EQUALITY AND RULE OF LAW

The continuing inability of the Philippine government to effectively apply the many laws designed to protect women and children so that their human rights are upheld and respected is caused by the very conservative and gender insensitive views of many of those tasked to administer justice.

Those views and mindsets are oftentimes observed by court users among Judges of designated Family Courts. Many Family Court Judges assert that families should remain solid and intact, despite complaints by many women that they suffer from physical and other forms of abuses from their husbands or partners.

Many Public Prosecutors and lawyers express their disgust during trainings and seminars on the Gender Sensitive Manner of Handling Cases. They share stories about certain judges who act in “despotic and arrogant manner” and berate lawyers in open court.

It has been shared many times over that in petitions for Protection Orders some designated Family Court Judges would ask the petitioners if they still love their spouses or partners. They oftentimes do that even if petitioners openly show in court the injuries or contusions they suffered because of the physical violence inflicted upon them by the respondents.

It has been reported that many judges disregard even the show of bruises by petitioners because once they hear the admission by petitioners that they still love their spouses or partners, the judges insist that the families must not be separated.

Many Judges are quoted making  statements like “Counsel, did you not hear that? This woman admits that she still loves her husband; so why are you breaking families?”. Most of the lawyers just keep silent in instances like this.

Many lawyers and Public Prosecutors complain that while they see the transformation in their ranks and many of them have become gender sensitive and responsive, the same is not true among Judges. This is one of the sad consequences of the continuing failure of our government to implement Republic Act 8369 for the Creation of Regular Family Courts.

The reality is that many of those functioning as Family Court Judges are not happy with what they call as their  “arbitrary designation”  as Family Court Judges. Many of them prefer to remain as Regular Court Judges.

This continuing anomalous situation in our justice system aggravates the many social ills that bug our communities. Marital and Family related issues are very delicate. Oftentimes, they create trauma, a lot of hatred and  of bitterness not only on the part of the spouses but most especially on the part of the children in the family.

There are now so many Children in Conflict with Laws. CICL oftentimes come from dysfunctional families. Many of these CICL have been exploited by criminal elements. Many of them have become drug users or drug dependents.

Many of these very sad and problematic situations would have been avoided if the designated Family Court Judges are able to do their functions in accordance with the provisions of Republic Act 8369.

Judges are leaders in their own right. If they use their leadership in facilitating disposal of cases that can lead to educating, enabling and empowering people, many of those who go to court can be healed, corrected and rehabilitated.

Republic Act 9262, the Anti-Violence Against Women and their Children Act of 2004 provides for two very important provisions that are not usually applied by the Family Courts. These provisions pertain to counseling and rehabilitation.

Section 40. Mandatory Programs and Services for Victims. The DSWD, and LGUs shall provide the victims temporary shelters, provide counseling, psycho-social services and/or, recovery, rehabilitation programs and livelihood assistance.

Section 41. Counseling and Treatment of Offenders. The DSWD shall provide rehabilitative counseling and treatment to perpetrators towards learning constructive ways of coping with anger and emotional outbursts and reforming their ways. When necessary, the offender shall be ordered by the Court to submit to psychiatric treatment or confinement.

Barangay Officials and Judges must take to heart the provision of Article 33 of RA 9262 which states:

Section 33. Prohibited Acts.- A Punong Barangay, Barangay Kagawad or the court hearing an application for protection order shall not order, direct, force or in any way unduly influence the applicant for protection order to compromise or abandon any of the reliefs sought in the application for protection order under this Act. Section 7 of the Family Court Acts of 1997 and 
Sections 410, 411, 412 and 413 of the Local Government Code of 1991 shall not apply in proceedings where relief is sought under this Act.

Failure to comply with this Section shall render the official or judge administratively liable.

Despite these very clear provisions of RA 9262, many victims of Violence continue to suffer. As a matter of fact, many private law practitioners who feel frustrated in handling cases on Violence Against Women and their Children (VAWC) no longer practice and they refuse to appear in courts.

It is in this regard that those tasked in the administration of justice must have a thorough understanding of the Cycle of Violence. The study of the Cycle of Violence (COV) have been shared by feminist-psychologists.

Many of the lawyer-advocates find the analyses by feminist-psychologists to be true in accordance with our own perception and experiences.

The repeated Cycle of Violence may eventually end up either in the death of the victim or the doer of violence. This happens once the victim acquires a Battered Woman Syndrome (BWS). Either way, there may be death unless counseling or psychiatric treatment can take place.

Death of either the battered woman or the doer of violence is very traumatic to family members. The cycle of violence must stop.

This cannot happen when judges will merely think of ensuring that families remain solid and intact without seeking for professional interventions. Victims must be healed to free them from the Battered Woman Syndrome.

RA 9262 provides:

Section 26. Battered Woman Syndrome as a Defense.- Victim-survivors who are found by the courts to be suffering from battered woman syndrome do not incur any criminal and civil liability nothwithstanding the absence of any of the elements for justifying circumstances of self defense under the Revised Penal Code.

In the determination of the state of mind of the woman who was suffering from battered woman syndrome at the time of the commission of the crime, the courts shall be assisted by expert psychiatrists/psychologists.

As discussed by expert psychologists and psychiatrists the Cycle of Violence illustrates the experience of the victim as follows:

It has three (3) recurring phases:

Ø  Tension or Build-Up Phase
Ø  Violent Outburst or Crisis Phase
Ø  Honeymoon Phase

In some instances, the cycle no longer goes through the honeymoon phase, rather it goes directly from the violent outburst to the built-in phase.

Tension Phase: 

Characterized by the increasing stress in the relationship and the couple cannot overcome by talking it out; 
The abuser wields control over his partner and dominates the situation;
·       Usually, threats, jealousy, and humiliation of the woman by the partner grow more serious;
     The former makes every effort to please the latter; 
     The woman is filled with fear and may try to deliberately ignore the problem

     Violent Outburst Phase: 
    
    Extreme physical violence or sexual or emotional harm occurs; 
     The batterer justifies his behavior as a way of teaching the woman a lesson;
·      The victim on the other hand, usually has no control of the outburst;
·      Her only recourse is a safe hiding place;
·      She may even deny the seriousness of the abuse and try to appease the batterer

Honeymoon Phase:
·     
 The batterer may feel remorse and sorrow for his behavior and may be fearful that his partner will leave him;
·      The batterer woos the victim and asks her forgiveness;
·      He promises not to repeat the abuse and his behavior may change for a while;
·      It may be a time of closeness for the couple.

     Of the three stages, the violent outburst stage is the most critical because the victim is often left scared and confused. In all stages, however, community intervention is needed in order to break the cycle of repeated violence completely.

RA 9262, the Anti Violence Against Women and their Children Act of 2004 is now an eleven year old law;

RA 8369, the Family Court Law of 1997 is now an eighteen year old law;

Yet the problem on VAWC is becoming worse.

We continue to call for our government to uphold and respect human rights gender equality and the rule of law.

Micah Chapter 6 verse 8 from the Old Testament of the Bible states:

“The Lord God has told us what is right and what he demands:
See that justice is done;
Let mercy be your first concern; and
Humbly obey your God.” (CEV)

Dory Cruz Avisado

9-1-15

Saturday, August 1, 2015

STRENGTHENING THE PCW (Part 2 ) ON HUMAN RIGHTS, GENDER EQUALITY AND RULE OF LAW

In the preceding Article we quoted the first three Sections of RA 9710, the Magna Carta of Women (MCW), to stress why we need to thoroughly understand the Human Rights of Women, as  well as ensure that we respect and uphold Gender Equality and the Rule of Law.

The Magna Carta of Women which is now a six (6) year old law is given much focus and attention by the various agencies of government including the Commission on Audit (COA) that checks on the proper use of their budget for mainstreaming Gender and Development, GAD.

Many government agencies, entities and instrumentalities are now doing  Gender Planning and Budgeting, GPB, as mandated by the various laws. The General Appropriations Act, GAA constantly include that provision where at least 5% of the budget of all government entities including State Universities and Colleges, SUCs, and Government Owned and Controlled Corporations, GOCCs, should be dedicated to mainstreaming GAD in their agencies.

Likewise, the Magna Carta of Women, mandates that 5% of the budget of all government agencies including SUCs and GOCCs should be used for their programs, activities and projects, PAPs on GAD. The Philippine Commission on Women (PCW), is mandated to take on the bulk of work to review the proposed GPBs of all those mandated to mainstream GAD. This means review of hundreds of GPBs  of various government agencies and instrumentalities.

Apart from the mandate to review and approve the various GPBs, PCW is also tasked to monitor and assess their Accomplishment Reports. Of course the biggest task which the PCW is mandated to do is the implementation of the Magna Carta of Women. 

Under Chapter 111 of the MCW, on the duties related to the Human Rights of Women it states:

The State, private sector, society in general, and all individuals shall contribute to the recognition, respect, and promotion of the rights of women defined and guaranteed under this Act.

Section 5. The State as the Primary Duty-Bearer.- The State as the primary duty bearer, shall:

(a)       Refrain from discriminating against women and violating their rights;
(b)       Protect women against discrimination and from violation of their rights by private corporations, entities, and individuals; and
(c)        Promote and fulfill the rights of women in all spheres, including their rights to substantive equality and non-discrimination.

The State shall fulfill these duties through law, policy, regulatory instruments, administrative guidelines, and other appropriate measures, including temporary special measures.

Recognizing the interrelation of the human rights of women, the State shall take measures and establish mechanisms to promote the coherent and integrated implementation and enforcement of this Act and related laws, policies, or other measures to effectively stop discrimination against and advance the rights of women.

The State shall keep abreast with and be guided by progressive developments in human rights of women under international law and design of policies, and other measures to promote the objectives of this Act.

The Philippines is very famous and well recognized for having passed progressive laws that provide for the protection of human rights of everyone. Programs on mainstreaming gender and development that promotes  gender equality and respect for the rule of law are well set. However, despite the existence of many beautiful laws human rights violations, gender discrimination and non-compliance of laws continue to persist.

The PCW is in a very strategic position to be able to check the proper implementation of the beautiful laws especially those that protect women and children. However, the PCW cannot cope up with a huge mandate, due the measly number of employees and personnel, as well as its very small annual budget.

It is humanely impossible for the PCW personnel to perform its tasks mandated by law considering how lean it is. The budget allocated by the government is also very small and many of the projects undertaken come from foreign grants and aids.

It is good that the PCW Board of Commissioners where several of us represent the private sector have asserted for the review of the PCW as an organization. We are glad that our government counterparts are very receptive about the proposal for upgrading this entity. Somehow, there is now hope that soon there will be an improvement of the PCW as a government agency.

One of the items I have stressed during a review of the functions of PCW  is the fact that the State is the primary duty bearer in ensuring that women’s human rights are always respected and upheld. I pointed out that as an organization tasked in monitoring implementation of many laws such as the MCW, it is ironic that there is no lawyer in the organization.

In the future, I hope that PCW would employ young and dynamic feminist lawyers who are passionate in ensuring that we will respect and uphold human rights, gender equality and rule of law in this country.

As I train Public Prosecutors from different parts of the country on the Gender Sensitive Manner of handling cases, I often hear them express their disgust on how some judges decide cases. Many Prosecutors raise the questionable manner by which some judges decide cases especially on Trafficking in Persons under Republic Act 9208 and also RA 9262, the Anti-Violence Against Women and their Children Act of 2004.

Some Prosecutors label the Family Court Judges before whom they appear to be "arrogant, despotic and gender insensitive."  They tell me that they do not intend to file administrative cases as this would only disrupt further the flow of cases they handle. They expressed that they only desire for the judges to change their attitude in handling cases.

Pursuant to the advocacy of the Transformative Justice Institute on "Truth Telling"  and "Enhancing the Communication Between the Judiciary and the Citizenry", which was part of the Blueprint of Action for Judicial Reform,  I have raised this concern to the Office of the Court Administrator, OCAD.
 The Honorable Supreme Court Administrator, Midas Marquez assured me that he is going to talk with the Judge mentioned by some Public Prosecutors. 

The Public Prosecutors also requested for a government entity to conduct regular research and monitoring to be able to establish  patterns of how gender insensitive and unresponsive are some orders and decisions of some judges. Many orders and decisions they say are highly questionable.

We are of course aware that under our jurisdiction once an accused is acquitted from cases, the People of the Philippines could no longer appeal due to the rule on double jeopardy. This rule however results in tremendous miscarriage of justice especially in cases involving women and children.

It is really sad that we hear of many stories that some accused are acquitted for several reasons and considerations. Several complainants have raised their Complaints to the UNCEDAW in the manner their cases were handled by trial court judges. UNCEDAW in a Communication involving the case of Karen Vertido found that the Philippine government is remiss in properly training the trial Judge who resorted to stereotyping in making the decision.

Now that there is an increase in the budget of the Judiciary we expect that proper trainings for Judges and Justices to become gender sensitive and responsive shall be carried out. Hopefully, the GAD Budget of the Judiciary shall be put to use in accordance with laws.

Public Prosecutors are willing to share stories of decided cases to Researchers and Monitors from the PCW.  There can be analyses of the whole record of decided cases to check on the pattern of some judges. The Legal group from PCW may also review decided cases by the Supreme Court and analyze how some “sexist language” continue to persist in their decisions. Of course we are all aware that lower courts oftentimes quote Supreme Court decisions.

The PCW can share its analyses of decided cases with the Philippine Judicial Academy,PHILJA, tasked in educating Justices, Judges and court personnel. Indeed, there is an urgency on the need to strengthen the Philippine Commission on Women. Let us all join hands in ensuring that this will be realized the soonest possible time.

The book of Psalm Chapter 103 verse 6 states: The Lord works righteousness and justice for all the oppressed.

Dory Cruz Avisado
8-1-15




Sunday, July 26, 2015

SEX AND GENDER (Part 1 ON HUMAN RIGHTS, GENDER EQUALITY AND RULE OF LAW)

In pushing for Mainstreaming Gender and Development (GAD) it is vital that we discuss human rights, gender equality and the rule of law.
Despite the fact that  Executive Order No.273 was issued in 1995 by President Fidel V. Ramos, mandating all government agencies, entities instrumentalities and government owned and controlled corporations (GOCCs), to mainstream gender and development from 1995 to 2025, the desired development has not really accelerated in accordance with our hearts’ desire for the past twenty years.
Nevertheless, I sense that the next ten years will create much difference. The interest shown by many of those in government to know the proper way of Gender Planning and Budgeting (GPBs) to ensure the proper use of the mandated 5% GAD Budget is very encouraging. Such interest is partly triggered by the very good performance of the Auditors from the Commission on Audit (COA), that properly check on the use of the budget.
In the past we heard that some government entities used their 5% GAD Budget for certain activities such as ballroom dancing, cooking and other projects that do not respond to the need to change peoples’ mindsets and attitudes for them to become gender sensitive and responsive so that they can become better individuals and citizens and likewise become better public servants.    
Gender sensitivity and responsiveness is very vital especially to people tasked in the administration of justice.
From the time I did trainings on Gender Law and Transformative Justice especially to group of lawyers where I put emphasis on Human Rights, Gender Equality and the Rule of Law, I received very encouraging feedbacks.
Many participants, in the various trainings I have conducted for lawyers, openly appreciate my call for all of us to do “truth telling” to identify the issues and concerns that we find at homes, workplaces and our communities that impact human rights, gender equality and the rule of law.
In all the workshops we have conducted for both lawyers and non-lawyers, always, their answers are YES to the question of whether they see human rights violations and gender discrimination at homes, workplaces and the communities. They readily identify the various causes of such human rights violations and gender discrimination. 
I get invited  a lot to lecture on Gender Law and Transformative Justice for the Mandatory Continuing Legal Education (MCLE) at the U.P. Law Center. This is a very positive development because lawyers are given the opportunity to know the basic concepts of Gender and Development. However, such lectures usually last for three hours only. There is no opportunity for us to conduct workshops. The most that we can do is to have very short open forums. It is heart warming that many lawyers have expressed that they want to further understand Gender and Development in relation to Human Rights, Gender Equality and the Rule of Law.
The introduction of the subject on Gender, Law and Transformative Justice to the MCLE is a progress in itself. Yet, many of the Public Prosecutors from the Department of Justice (DOJ) who recently attended and deeply appreciated the 3 day trainings on the Gender Sensitive Manner of Handling  Cases strongly recommended that other lawyers from the Public Attorneys’ Office and even private practitioners should also do workshop seminars so that they have a thorough and deeper understanding of GAD for them to be transformed. That way they say, as officers of the court, they will not just be concerned about winning or losing cases but be concerned about proper and ethical administration of justice that can lead to respect for the rule of law and sustainable human development.
Another important clamor from the Public Prosecutors is, for the Courts, as one of the 8 pillars of the Criminal Justice System to make sure that the Judges before whom they appear are also gender sensitive and responsive.  They assert that while it is  vital for more lawyers to understand Gender Law and Transformative Justice, the Judges must be in the front lines in advancing gender sensitivity and responsiveness.  Indeed, there is an urgent need for Judges and Justices to be gender sensitive for them to be just, fair and  ethical in their administration of justice.

For the next six months, up to December this year, I will write about Gender, Law and Transformative Justice in relation to Human Rights, Gender Equality and the Rule of Law.  
For this article let me start to stress the importance of knowing the difference between SEX and GENDER.
When we refer to sex it is the biological aspect of a person. We would immediately identify the sex of a person upon birth. One is either male or female. They are identified as such on the basis of their genitalia. The male has penis and scrotum while the female has vagina.

Except for the biological aspects of human beings of which they were born with, everything else are gender or social construct. That is why every human person must be respected and their rights upheld regardless of their Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity (SOGI).

As of now a Magna Carta of Women, Republic Act 9710, has been in effect and is being implemented in the Philippines since 2009. The importance of this law can be gleaned from the first  four sections which provide, to wit:

SECTION 1.   Short Title. — This Act shall be known as “The Magna Carta of Women”.

SECTION 2.          Declaration of Policy. — Recognizing that the economic, political, and socio cultural realities affect women’s current condition, the State affirms the role of women in nation building and ensures the substantive equality of women and men. It shall promote empowerment of women and pursue equal opportunities for women and men and ensure equal access to resources and to development results and outcome. Further, the State realizes that equality of men and women entails the abolition of the unequal structures and practices that perpetuate discrimination and inequality. To realize this, the State shall endeavor to develop plans, policies, programs, measures, and mechanisms to address discrimination and inequality in the economic, political, social, and cultural life of women and men.

The State condemns discrimination against women in all its forms and pursues by all appropriate means and without delay the policy of eliminating discrimination against women in keeping with the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) and other international instruments consistent with Philippine law. The State shall accord women the rights, protection, and opportunities available to every member of society.

The State affirms women’s rights as human rights and shall intensify its efforts to fulfill its duties under international and domestic law to recognize, respect, protect, fulfill, and promote all human rights and fundamental freedoms of women, especially marginalized women, in the economic, social, political, cultural, and other fields without distinction or discrimination on account of class, age, sex, gender, language, ethnicity, religion, ideology, disability, education, and status.

The State shall provide the necessary mechanisms to enforce women’s rights and adopt and undertake all legal measures necessary to foster and promote the equal opportunity for women to participate in and contribute to the development of the political, economic, social, and cultural realms.

The State, in ensuring the full integration of women’s concerns in the mainstream of development, shall provide ample opportunities to enhance and develop their skills, acquire productive employment and contribute to their families and communities to the fullest of their capabilities.

In pursuance of this policy, the State reaffirms the right of women in all sectors to participate in policy formulation, planning, organization, implementation, management, monitoring, and evaluation of all programs, projects, and services. It shall support policies, researches, technology, and training programs and other support services such as financing, production, and marketing to encourage active participation of women in national development.

SECTION 3.          Principles of Human Rights of Women. — Human rights are universal and inalienable. All people in the world are entitled to them. The universality of human rights is encompassed in the words of Article 1 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which states that all human beings are free and equal in dignity and rights.

Human rights are indivisible. Human rights are inherent to the dignity of every human being whether they relate to civil, cultural, economic, political, or social issues.

Human rights are interdependent and interrelated. The fulfillment of one right often depends, wholly or in part, upon the fulfillment of others.

All individuals are equal as human beings by virtue of the inherent dignity of each human person. No one, therefore, should suffer discrimination on the basis of ethnicity, gender, age, language, sexual orientation, race, color, religion, political, or other opinion, national, social, or geographical origin, disability, property, birth, or other status as established by human rights standards.

All people have the right to participate in and access information relating to the decision-making processes that affect their lives and well-being. Rights-based approaches require a high degree of participation by communities, civil society, minorities, women, young people, indigenous peoples, and other identified groups.

States and other duty-bearers are answerable for the observance of human rights. They have to comply with the legal norms and standards enshrined in international human rights instruments in accordance with the Philippine Constitution. Where they fail to do so, aggrieved rights-holders are entitled to institute proceedings for appropriate redress before a competent court or other adjudicator in accordance with the rules and procedures provided by law.

Under Section 4 in the Definition of Terms are the following:

       (b)     “Discrimination Against Women” refers to any gender-based distinction, exclusion, or restriction which has the effect or purpose of impairing or nullifying the recognition, enjoyment, or exercise by women, irrespective of their marital status, on a basis of equality of men and women, of human rights and fundamental freedoms in the political, economic, social, cultural, civil, or any other field.

It includes any act or omission, including by law, policy, administrative measure, or practice, that directly or indirectly excludes or restricts women in the recognition and promotion of their rights and their access to and enjoyment of opportunities, benefits, or privileges.

A measure or practice of general application is discrimination against women if it fails to provide for mechanisms to offset or address sex or gender-based disadvantages or limitations of women, as a result of which women are denied or restricted in the recognition and protection of their rights and in their access to and enjoyment of opportunities, benefits, or privileges; or women, more than men, are shown to have suffered the greater adverse effects of those measures or practices.

Provided, finally, that discrimination compounded by or intersecting with other grounds, status, or condition, such as ethnicity, age, poverty, or religion shall be considered discrimination against women under this Act.

 Clearly, neither of the sexes should be considered superior over the other. Males and females are human beings with the same human rights which should be respected and upheld.
Human rights of every individual should be upheld and respected regardless of their Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity (SOGI). They must never be discriminated against in any field of endeavor at homes, workplaces and the communities.
Gender discrimination or biases happen when there is marginalization, subordination, stereotyping and multiple burden.
Therefore, as we uphold and respect human rights of everyone, we push for gender equality and uphold and likewise respect the rule of law.
Galatians Chapter 3 verse 28 states:
“There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is no male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.”
Dory Cruz Avisado
July 26, 2015


Tuesday, June 30, 2015

OUR ROLE IN NATION BUILDING


In the preceding article I quoted the teachings of Jesus Christ about the Wise and Foolish Builders from the Book of Matthew Chapter 7 verses 24 to 27. It is vital to heed such Biblical admonition in our nation building so that we will have a truly strong nation which would not collapse due to so many challenges including the literal storms which our country experience from year to year.

So many interesting things are happening in our country today that should inspire all of us to help in the nation building. We must all be wise builders.

The pervasive intertwining culture of corruption, patriarchy and impunity  in our midst shaped our nation for what it is today, weak and vulnerable. We have repeatedly mentioned that dirty politics has a lot to do with our present system.

In Development Studies we are taught that we the Filipino people, can re-shape our culture which includes the culture of politics.We can become a strong nation with upright people, that value honesty and truth. We must be a nation respectful of Human Rights, Gender Equality and the Rule of Law.   

The 1987 Philippine Constitution under Article 11 on Declaration of Principles and State Policies provide the following:

Section 13. The State recognizes the vital role of the youth in nation-building and shall promote and protect their physical, moral, spiritual, intellectual, and social well-being. It shall inculcate in the youth patriotism and nationalism, and encourage their involvement in public and civic affairs.

Section 14. The State recognizes the role of women in nation-building, and shall ensure the fundamental equality before the law of women and men.


These provisions should remind us that no matter who we are, whatever our age or sex, we have a role to play in nation building.

In the kind of work I do as a full time Advocate for the Transformation of the Philippine Justice System, I am blessed to be able to talk with various groups of people. I always treasure the many opportunities to talk with groups of women and the youth. I always encourage them to take part in nation building.  We should not just leave that important task to the men as we can all contribute even in the world  of politics. We cannot just continue to complain about how dirty is politics in this country and not participate in transforming the same.

Personally, I was never enticed to get into partisan politics. I simply find it not to be my line or as others say, “it Is not my cup of tea.” Despite this, I am a keen observer of political developments not only in the Philippines but other parts of the world as well.

As a doctoral graduate and as professor of Development Studies, I am able to interact  with other people who are also interested in this field. I interact with academicians, lawyers, medical doctors, business people, government workers, other professionals, and non-professionals  that come from all sides of the political spectrum.

Many of us agree that the political system in our country needs to be overhauled. If we really like to attain genuine peace and development in our country, politics should not be left to the politicians.
We must all be involved not necessarily thru partisan politics but in discussions that shall strengthen our political system. We should also focus on issues and concerns that need to be advanced that can ensure socio-economic development that will eradicate poverty in our country.

In order for us to have good political leaders we must stop the practice of voting for the popular ones who do not have clear agenda or platform of government. Our group has been closely monitoring who among the candidates will uphold and respect Human Rights, Gender Equality and the Rule of Law.

Foremost we ask, who among the candidates have clear understanding of the need to counter the present intertwining culture of corruption patriarchy and impunity and will push for the transformation of our justice system?

We need leaders who are visionaries. Our leaders must be fully committed to serve our country and our people and not just an interest group. 

Our leaders must be firm believers of God but know how to discern the concept of separation of Church and State so that appropriate policies and legislation needed by the people are passed.

Our leaders must have basic understanding of the Philippine Constitution and know the functions of the great branches of the government; the concept of separation of power; the essence of checks and balances and how the democratic system works.

Our leaders must be open to transparency, accountability and responsibility in governance and will be judicious in their use and management of the people’s money.

We like our leaders to be upright and honest but at the same time we want them to be competent, fair, just, and compassionate.

To be realistic we cannot still find at this point in time the leaders that will totally fit all that we want and so we will be constrained to settle for the ones that will closely suit our criteria. Still, we need to openly declare to the public what we want in our leaders. We need to articulate what platform of government and agenda we want them to carry and subsequently implement. By doing this we will slowly but surely  influence how politics will shape in our country.

More than fifty percent of our population are women, if women will do their role in nation building along with the youth, we can soon achieve what the Preamble of the Philippine Constitution would like for us to attain.

We can start by identifying who are those submitting themselves for election in 2016 who are committed to build a just and humane society?

Who are committed to establish a Government that shall embody our ideals and aspirations, and promote the common good?

Who among them shall conserve and develop our patrimony ?

Who among them shall secure to ourselves and our posterity, the blessings of independence and 
democracy under the rule of law?

Who among them will advance a regime of truth, justice, freedom, love, equality, and peace?

Who among those offering themselves to become our political leaders for 2016 to 2022 have concrete plans, programs and projects that can ensure the much needed social, economic, cultural and political development in our country?

All of us, women, men, youth and everyone else must consider seriously our role in nation building. Let us demand for quality leadership in our country.

Here are some selected verses from Proverbs chapter 29 that may guide us :

Verse 2. When the righteous thrive, the people rejoice; when the wicked rule, the people groan;

Verse 4. By justice a king gives a country stability, but one who is greedy for bribes tear it down.

Verse 7. The righteous care about justice for the poor, but the wicked have no such concern.

Verse 10. Bloodthirsty people hate people of integrity and seek to kill the upright.

Verse 11. Fools give full vent to their anger but wise people keep themselves under control.

Verse 12. If rulers listen to lies, all their officials become wicked.

Dory Cruz Avisado
6-30-2015   

  


Thursday, May 28, 2015

IMPARTIALITY

As a long time advocate for the transformation of the Philippine Justice System many are awed at the level of hope that I continue to express "that there will be a turn around." Things shall change for as long as we believe it can happen and we act decisively in pursuing the much needed transformation.

A very clear indicator for me that change is already starting albeit slowly, is the kind of openness that many of our citizens have started to demonstrate. Those who deliberately discuss and now advocate for the transformation of the Philippine Justice System include practicing lawyers.

It is heart warming that whenever I finish my presentation on Gender Law and Transformative Justice among lawyers either for their Mandatory Continuing Legal Education (MCLE), or for groups of government lawyers for the required program on Mainstreaming Gender and Development (GAD) in their offices, several participants would later approach me and ask permission  to use my materials in sharing the same to their communities. I readily say yes. 

I can see that we have  a growing number of concerned citizens who are actively involved in countering the intertwining culture of corruption patriarchy and impunity. Even among progressive media practitioners and netizens you hear and read a lot of comments regarding "justice for sale" and  "selective justice" under the present administration.

We need to look at our present situation with positive light and be fully convinced of the growing recognition that there can never be a genuine peace and sustainable development unless we have a working justice system in this country.

Many people readily agree about how weak are the various pillars of the Criminal Justice System in our country. They ask what can we do concretely to transform without glorifying the shortcut manner of resolving crimes like summary executions which are clearly violative of Human Rights and the Rule of Law?

Changing our values and mindsets is a necessity. We need to go back to the basics in the administration of justice where those tasked to administer the same, do uphold and respect the Rule of Law. By this, it simply means that administrators of justice need to be impartial, and will always act in accordance with law.

For genuine development to take place we must always allow the law to take its course. No matter who are involved in violating the law, our government should  properly file charges and cause the conviction for them to be properly disciplined regardless of their political alliances.Administrators of justice  should not be selective on who should be charged if evidence warrants.

As perceived by many advocates there is truth to the observation that many of those tasked to administer justice are selective in their actions that tend to favor personalities that belong to certain political groups. By way of example, many of those perceived to be close to the administration are not charged as expeditiously as possible of graft and corruption despite the testimony of witnesses and pronouncements made in the past by those investigating cases involving the PDAF, which was declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court. 

Having conducted researches about the needed transformation, I have loads of suggestions in that regard some of which were already written in this Transformative Justice blog. Several of the recommendations require amendment of the constitution but many of our suggestions involve merely changing of attitudes and mindsets.

Right attitudes and mindsets by those tasked to administer justice should be in accordance with the admonition  by prophet Micah from the Old Testament in Chapter 6 verse 8, which states "What does the Lord require of you but to act justly, love mercy and to walk humbly with God."

That clearly means that to become a just administrator of justice one should act with impartiality and  simply apply the rule of law. It is basic that one has to love God and country above all else.

The big question is, among those who are holding positions of power tasked to administer justice; who are performing their duties and responsibilities with God in their hearts and are loving our country and our people?

Who among our leaders will put the interest of our country and the people over and above their political alliances and interests to remain in power?

The questions we have raised are not easy to answer due to many complexities that have affected our culture. Now our country and people are suffering from the intertwining culture of corruption patriarchy and impunity.

As citizens who love God and country, we need to help build a nation that will respect and uphold Human Rights Gender Equality and the Rule of Law at all times. This means that all of us must work together in ensuring that the justice system will be transformed the way it should be, as envisioned in the Preamble of the Philippine Constitution which I again quote here:

We the sovereign Filipino people, imploring the aid of Almighty God, in order to build a just and humane society and establish a government that shall embody our ideals and aspirations, promote the common good, conserve and develop our patrimony, and secure to ourselves and our posterity the blessings of independence and democracy under the rule of law and regime of truth, justice, freedom, love, equality, and peace do ordain and promulgate this constitution. 

In this regard, we need to discern very well who are the right political leaders to elect during the 2016 elections. Who among the political leaders will uphold Human Rights Gender Equality and the Rule of Law? Who among them understand the need to transform our justice system and can offer a concrete platform to carry out a program on transforming the justice system?

In the meantime, let us continue the call for impartiality in the administration of justice so that everyone who violated our laws can be held accountable.

As we work together in strengthening the different structures and institutions for us to attain a transformed justice system which is necessary for nation building, we need wisdom and guidance in our directions and actions. It is good to always ask the question, WWJD, What would Jesus do?

Our Lord, Master Savior and King Jesus, the Christ, reminded us about the Narrow and Wide Gates and the Wise and Foolish Builders in Matthew Chapter 7 verses 13 and 14 and 24 to 27 as he states:

Enter through the narrow gate. For wide is the gate and broad is the road that leads to destruction, and many enter through it. But small is the gate and narrow the road that leads to life, and only a few find it. 

Therefore everyone who hears these words of mine and puts them into practice is like a wise man who built his house on the rock. The rain came down, the streams rose, and the winds blew and beat against that house; yet it did not fall, because it had its foundation on the rock. But everyone who hears these words of mine and does not put them into practice is like a foolish man who built his house on the sand. The rain came down, the stream rose, and the winds blew and beat against the house, and it fell with a great crash. (NIV)

Dory Cruz Avisado
5-28-15





Saturday, April 25, 2015

LEGACY FOR JUDICIAL REFORM

It has been eleven years from the time I tendered my irrevocable resignation as Presiding Judge of the Regional Trial Court Branch 9 in Davao City in order to fully advocate for the transformation of the Philippine Justice System.

 Along with the members of my family Wendel, Gemma and Ethel, we established our self-funded family ministries thru the Avisado Advocacy Consultancy Counseling and Christian Teaching and Training Services Center,  AACCCTTS Center. Through the center, we established various programs where we dedicate our God given talents and resources to be of service to God and our country. Under the umbrella of the AACCCTTS Center is the Transformative Justice Institute (TJI) also simultaneously established eleven years ago.

The Transformative Justice Institute (TJI) is the main vehicle we use in the advocacy for the transformation of the justice system. We feel so blessed that we are able to establish nationwide networks and linkages that support our call for people to do Truth Telling about their experiences in the various pillars of the justice system.

Now we have so many allies that push our government in constructive, active non-violent ways of transforming society and strengthening the various structures, pillars, and institutions charged with the administration of justice in order to slay and counter the Intertwining Culture of Corruption Patriarchy and Impunity in our Justice System. Many of our allies also come from the various pillars of the justice system that are under government employ and of course those that belong to the Community Pillar of Justice.

Young lawyers in our family, that includes our daughter Atty. Ethel Avisado and her cousin Atty. Arnold Abejaron, for the past five years have taken the tasks of being the Executive Officer, and Deputy Executive Officer respectively of the TJI where I served for six years as the Founding Executive Director. I now serve as the Chair of TJI.

The beauty in our working arrangements is that we have certain other works where we generate modest incomes but are still able to effectively carry out our self-imposed mandates on a voluntary basis for the TJI. We are aware that we are attaining this degree of success because God is blessing our work. Thus we always say "To God Be the Glory, Padayon ta (Let's carry on)."

In our recent family retreat, we all expressed our gratefulness and profuse thanksgiving to God and to each other our joy and happiness regarding  the extent of achievements of  our small  family advocacy. We fully acknowledge that it is God's will that we are able to achieve some degree of success in pushing for the transformation of the Philippine Justice System. As a family, we acknowledge that we are but instruments of God in doing good things and we all agreed that everything we do would be our form of service to God and country. We are trying to be good followers and disciples of our Lord, Master and King Jesus Christ.

Part of the blessings that we acknowledge is my having been appointed by President Benigno Aquino III, PNOY, as Commissioner of the Philippine Commission on Women (PCW) representing the Elderly and Persons With Disability. Apart from taking up the concerns of the sector I represent in the Board, I am able to recommend other concerns  based on my experience and what we see on the ground which oftentimes are products of our regular dialogues with all the pillars of justice.

Being with the PCW also gives me the opportunity to help implement our government's program in Mainstreaming Gender and Development (GAD). Thru the PCW, our long time advocacy for Human Rights, Gender Equality and Rule of Law can be further intensified. 

In the recent Board of Commissioners meeting of the Philippine Commission on Women (PCW), the PCW technical staff presented various accomplishments which they hope will be included in President Aquino's last State of the Nation Address (SONA), in July of this year.

I suggested as part of our recommendations for the President's SONA, is the inclusion of  his commitment to the nation that part of his programs for his last year in office shall be  the implementation of Republic Act 8369 for the creation of the Regular Family Courts in the Philippines.

 RA 8369 is an 18 year old law which has not been implemented due to the failure of the past administrations to allocate the needed funds. This segment of Judicial Reform  has been acknowledged by the government since 1997 and sadly due to unexplained reasons, government continue to neglect its duty in complying with its mandate that should benefit Filipino families.

The continuing failure of the Philippine government to implement RA 8369 is a clear indication that many of our political leaders continue to lack the much needed appreciation and sensitivity regarding the proper administration of justice for cases involving marriages, families, children, and the youth particularly Children In Conflict with Laws (CICL) that fall within the jurisdiction of the Family Courts. I asked the PCW technical personnel to refer to the September 2013 post in this blog for a more elaborate discussion regarding the need for Regular Family Courts.

Despite the reality that the present administration has barely over a year to govern, it can show political will to create a big impact in the much needed Judicial Reform by doing a last ditch effort in implementing and enforcing RA 8369 as part of its legacy. The entire country will surely benefit from this much needed action from the government. The continuing neglect of the political leaders to do its part in implementing RA 8369 is a main factor in the continuing saga of miscarriages of justice and lack of healing on the part of the millions of families which have become dysfunctional.

While the bigger aspiration for an independent and clean Judiciary will surely take longer time to achieve, implementing RA 8369 is a very easy one. If the President will ask the Department of Budget and Management (DBM) and Congress to allocate funds for the creation of the Regular Family Courts, surely, it can be done under the present administration.

Dysfunctional relationships in families cause so many children to feel traumatized. Many of them become bitter in life and carry so much hatred in their hearts. Sadly,  many of the Acting Family Court Judges, whose branches of the Regional Trial Courts were  designated by the Supreme Court as Family Courts  to handle cases falling under RA 8369, are unable to properly administer justice. Such situations cause further trauma to families especially the women and children.

The counseling that RA 8369 stresses, that should pave the way for healing of traumatized victims of Domestic Violence and correction and rehabilitation of the doers of violence, does not take place.

The present situation which contribute to the erosion of faith of many citizens including lawyers in the courts system has reached the point that many do prefer alternative actions  to help dysfunctional families. However, concerned groups mostly NGOs and Church Based Organizations (CBOs), can only do so much. The government  has the primary mandate to help dysfunctional families. It has the resources to do so.

Here are some relevant provisions of the Constitution that the government should  uphold for the protection of  human rights of everyone. These provisions of the Constitution are also part of the grounds which the Transformative Justice Institute is advancing in support of the passage of a Divorce Law.  I discussed the need for Divorce Law in my preceding article for March, and the urgency of the implementing  RA 8369, which hopefully PNOY will decide to be part of his legacy.

Under Article II of the 1987 Constitution in the Declaration of Principles and State Policies several provisions call for the promotion of the general welfare of all citizens and for the dignity and worth of every person as part of their human rights, to wit:

Section 5. The maintenance of peace and order, the protection of life, liberty and property, and promotion of the general welfare are essential for the enjoyment by all the people of the blessings of democracy.

The peace and order mentioned under Section 5  include the much needed peace at homes and families and of course the communities. However due to the inability of the government to properly implement the good laws and to create the appropriate machinery as envisioned under RA 8369, the above provision of the Constitution is not being upheld and enjoyed by many people, including hundreds of thousands if not millions of women and children in the Philippines who are victims of Domestic Violence.


Section 9. The State shall promote a just and dynamic social order that will ensure the prosperity and dynamic social order that will ensure the prosperity and independence of the nation and free the people from poverty through policies that provide adequate social services, promote full employment, a rising standard of living and an improved quality of life for all.

The quality of the lives of many of those who belong to dysfunctional families are oftentimes miserable. Their productivity are oftentimes affected. Government must realize that such situation does not only affect the families but the society at large.


Section 11. The State values the dignity of every human person and guarantees full respect for human rights.

Due to the failure of government to pass the much needed Divorce Law and to properly implement RA 8369 many Filipinos with dysfunctional families, especially women and children continue to suffer in miserable living conditions which are clearly violative of their human rights.

Section 13. The State recognizes the vital role of the youth in nation building and shall promote and protect their physical, moral, spiritual, intellectual and social well being. It shall inculcate in the youth patriotism and nationalism, and encourage their involvement in public and civic affairs.

Many of our youths have become CICL due to lack of proper guidance from their parents. Oftentimes the parents due to unresolved conflicts and problems in their marriages neglect their parental roles as they are not able to cope with the family troubles and conflicts . If we have the right functioning Family Courts these kinds of problems may find solutions facilitated thru Counseling and proper administration of justice.


Section 14. The State shall protect working women by providing safe and healthful working conditions, taking into account their maternal functions, and such facilities and opportunities that will enhance their welfare and enable them to realize their full potential in the service of the nation.

Many women and children who are victims of violence are not amply protected under the present system. Thus there is an urgent need to ensure that all structures to ensure the enforcement of the above provisions of law are realized. This is one of the strong grounds for the passage of RA 8369.

Finally, Article  XIII of the Constitution  on Social Justice and Human Rights provide the following:

Section 1. The Congress shall give highest priority to the enactment of measures that protect and enhance the right of all the people to human dignity, reduce social, economic, and political inequalities by equitably diffusing wealth and political power for the common good.

Let us all pray that PNOY will leave a legacy of implementing one of the most vital laws passed 18 years ago which previous administrations failed to implement. After all it is all in his hands as well as in the hands of the members of Congress. Along with the Filipino nation, the Supreme Court is just waiting for the Executive and Legislative Branches of government to do their part.

Ecclesiastes Chapter 5 verses 8 to 10 states:

If you see the poor oppressed in a district, and justice and rights denied, do not be surprised at such things; for one official is eyed by a higher one, and one of them both are higher still. The increase from the land is taken by all; the king himself profits from the fields. Whoever loves money never has money enough; whoever loves wealth is never satisfied with his income. This too is meaningless.


Dory Cruz Avisado
4-25-15